1000+ 5-Star Reviews and One Non-Traditional Vision: How Google Reviews Redefined George Duffield and National Integrity Title Agency's Destiny

It was an ordinary afternoon in 2014. George Duffield, a title insurance industry veteran, was chatting with a real estate agent about grabbing lunch. The colleague casually suggested a nearby Vietnamese restaurant, but never one to settle for just “ok,” George pulled out his phone to check its Google reviews. What he found stopped him cold: a handful of scattered and uninspiring reviews, barely scraping a passing grade. No way was he eating there. Instead, he scrolled for a spot with glowing, five-star praise and pitched it to the agent.

That snap decision to skip the lackluster restaurant didn’t just save their meal; it lit a spark in George that would blaze through his company, National Integrity Title Agency - NITA. But inciting a revolution is one thing; sustaining it within a skeptical industry would test every ounce of his resolve.

George entered the title insurance industry in 2011, stepping into a world that felt stuck in the past – one filled with often invisible companies barely advertising, rarely online, and sometimes lacking even a basic Google Business page. Many didn’t have websites, let alone a digital footprint. For George this was an opportunity to redefine tradition and challenge the status quo. If consumers were “googling” restaurants, hotels and even real estate agents, why wouldn’t they search for title insurance companies? He leaned into a mantra that would become his guiding star: Unseen, untold, unsold – if people don’t see you, they won’t Buy You. So, he decided to make NITA impossible to miss.

The pivot to prioritize Google reviews wasn’t just a whim; it was a calculated move to stand out in a crowded, faceless industry. But getting reviews was tougher than expected. Fresh from settlement, homeowners were eager to grab their keys and go, not pause to write a glowing testimonial. George and his team had to get creative. They set KPIs, tracking weekly and monthly review goals. They stopped clients at the closing table and sent follow ups via their AI assistant, Robin.  “But, why just the buyer?” George asked. “Everyone we work with, realtors, processors, vendors, can tell our story.” This relentless crusade paid off, but not without hurdles. Some in the industry scoffed, calling marketing a joke. Others questioned if there were risks for overpromoting the brand. This included Fran, George’s partner.

Fran is a master of operations, ensuring every title was clean and insurable. More of a traditionalist, she was skeptical of social media, public exposure and negative reviews. But she trusted George and his passionate view of the bigger picture. “Negative reviews happen – each one an opportunity to improve,” he admitted. “We’re at 4.9 stars, not 5.0, and when they come, we pick up the phone, talk it out, and fix it.” Once, a scathing review hit their page, only for George to realize it was meant for a competitor. A quick call and some clarifying photos got it removed. Another time, a realtor’s fumble got pinned on them, but George refused to throw her under the bus; she sent them 150 deals a year. Instead, he coached her to make it right. In both instances, this proactive approach turned potential disasters into trust building moments. But to this day, it requires constant vigilance.

The real proof of George’s strategy came when a savvy consumer preparing to buy a property was nudged toward a real estate agent’s joint venture title insurance company. But the buyer did their homework, googling to find the in-house agency had just three or four reviews, barely a whisper online. Then they stumbled on NITA, boasting nearly 1,000 five star reviews, press releases, and a vibrant community presence. “Why would I go with them when this company looks like they’re doing it right?” the buyer challenged. The agent mumbled about convenience, but the consumer wasn’t swayed. But the consumer chose George and the NITA team, proving that “unseen, untold, unsold” wasn’t just a catchy phrase; it was a business lifeline.

Read Full Magazine

Those 1,000+ reviews weren’t a marketing flex; they were a testament to National Integrity’s ironclad processes. “Marketing without process is nothing,” George insisted. His team used tools like ClosingLock for secure transactions, educated clients with a “pizza tracker” mindset, and maintained transparency through press releases and social media. They even advertised internally, shouting out staff achievements in newsletters to boost retention. But staying ahead meant more than just reviews. George was always “looking around the corner before getting to the corner.” Growing up in Philadelphia’s tough Kensington neighborhood taught him to anticipate challenges. “You survive by seeing what’s coming,” he said. “In business, you create wider lanes to be here tomorrow. If you’re content with your current lane, you’re out.”

That foresight drove National Integrity to innovate constantly. They hired a writer to ensure every press release popped, and the company as well as its staff received well-deserved recognition. A dedicated social media team kept their feeds fresh, mixing professional posts with quirky content to stay visible. When they onboarded a new employee in Northfield, they blasted the news across Facebook groups and local journals, instantly drawing in her network. Why push out this seemingly small update across social media? According to George, “Because title insurance professionals think they’re in the title insurance business. But the truth is, we’re in the marketing business specializing in title insurance.” So, small updates reflecting that mindset can go a long way in keeping your company in front of your audience.

As George’s vision took hold, NITA thrived, but the irony of that 2014 lunch… The Vietnamese restaurant with the lackluster reviews? It’s closed now, a ghost of a business that didn’t adapt. The real estate agent from that day? Out of business, too, having never embraced marketing. “They didn’t see the value,” George reflected. “Realtors, restaurants, title insurance companies – if you’re not shouting your story, a story, from the rooftops, you’re done.”

National Integrity Title Agency, meanwhile, stands tall. Its 1,000+ reviews a beacon for educated consumers. George’s story isn’t just about surviving; it’s about thriving – looking ahead, staying consistent, and living by the truth that “unseen, untold, unsold” is the death knell of any business. And every morning, he wakes up ready to look around the next corner.